SEP IRA vs Solo 401(k): Which Actually Fits a One-Person Business
Six dimensions, three income levels and the break-even where one plan overtakes the other. A decision page, not a list of features.
The honest answer to “SEP IRA or Solo 401(k)” is that the SEP is simpler and the Solo 401(k) holds more money. Which one wins depends on how much you want to contribute, whether you want Roth treatment, and whether you are willing to file one more form once the account grows.
Below is the comparison with numbers, not adjectives. If your net profit is under $50,000 and you want the least paperwork, the SEP usually wins. Above $150,000, the Solo 401(k) usually wins on capacity. Between the two, it depends on how much you are actually trying to save.
The six differences that matter
| Dimension | SEP IRA | Solo 401(k) |
|---|---|---|
| Maximum contribution | 25% of compensation, about 20% of net SE income, capped at $75,000 for 2027 | $25,500 employee deferral plus about 20% employer, capped at $75,000 combined |
| Roth option | No | Yes, if the plan permits designated Roth contributions |
| Loans | Not permitted | Permitted if the plan allows |
| Setup | One form at a brokerage | Plan document plus account, more paperwork |
| Annual filing | None | Form 5500-EZ once plan assets exceed $250,000 |
| Contribution deadline | Tax filing deadline, including extensions | Employer share by the filing deadline; employee deferral by December 31 |
The first row is the one that decides most cases. A SEP can only hold the employer contribution. A Solo 401(k) can hold the employer contribution plus a deferral, which is why it reaches higher totals at the same profit.
Same income, both plans
Using 2027 limits and a sole proprietor under 50:
| Net profit | SEP IRA maximum | Solo 401(k) maximum | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| $40,000 | $7,435 | $32,935 | +$25,500 |
| $100,000 | $18,587 | $44,087 | +$25,500 |
| $200,000 | $37,177 | $62,677 | +$25,500 |
| $300,000 | $55,766 | $75,000 (capped) | +$19,234 |
The pattern is consistent: at these incomes the Solo 401(k) is ahead by the deferral amount until the overall cap binds. The SEP catches up only when profit is high enough that the employer contribution alone approaches $75,000 — roughly $375,000 of net profit for a sole proprietor.
When the SEP is the better choice
- You want the least ongoing administration. No plan document, no annual Form 5500-EZ, no deferral election.
- You decide at filing time. The SEP contribution can be made up to the extended due date of the return, so a profitable year can be offset after the books are closed.
- You are contributing a modest amount. If you are saving $5,000–$10,000, the extra capacity of a Solo 401(k) is theoretical.
- You already have a SEP from a prior business. Contributing to the existing plan is simpler than opening a second one, though a Solo 401(k) can coexist.
When the Solo 401(k) wins
- You want to max out. The deferral is the only way to get $25,500 into the plan on top of the employer share.
- You want Roth treatment. A Solo 401(k) can accept designated Roth contributions if the plan document allows them. A SEP IRA cannot.
- You may hire. A Solo 401(k) can be expanded to cover employees; a SEP can too, but the contribution is a flat percentage for everyone.
- You want a loan provision. Not all plans offer loans, but a SEP never does.
- You are comfortable with one more form. Form 5500-EZ is filed annually once plan assets exceed $250,000. Below that threshold, no filing is required.
The Roth trade-off
Roth contributions are after-tax: you give up the deduction now and take the money out tax-free in retirement. For a business owner in a low-income year, that can be the better trade. For someone in a high bracket, the deduction is usually worth more than the future exclusion.
A SEP IRA has no Roth version. If Roth treatment is a requirement, the decision is over — choose the Solo 401(k).
Administrative reality
The Form 5500-EZ threshold is $250,000 in plan assets, measured at the end of the prior year. A solo plan that started with $30,000 a year will cross it eventually. Once it does, the filing is annual and the penalty for missing it is not trivial. That is the main hidden cost of the Solo 401(k), and it arrives years after the decision.
Neither plan requires an ERISA bond or an audit at this size. Both require you to keep contribution records and to follow the plan document for distributions and loans.
A decision rule
- Under $50,000 profit, saving less than $15,000: SEP. The simplicity is worth more than the unused capacity.
- Under $50,000 profit, wanting to save aggressively: Solo 401(k). The deferral roughly quadruples what you can put away.
- $50,000–$150,000 profit: Solo 401(k) if you will use the deferral or want Roth; SEP if you will not.
- Above $150,000 profit: Solo 401(k) unless the administration is genuinely unmanageable, in which case a SEP plus a taxable brokerage account is a defensible second choice.
What this page does not do
It does not cover defined-benefit plans, cash balance plans, or a plan that covers employees, and it does not evaluate the investment options at any particular custodian. Contribution limits are for 2027; confirm them against IR-2026-136 before you contribute. If you are choosing between plans with a spouse’s employer plan in the picture, the coordination rules add another layer — get that reviewed.
Written by Solo & Cents Editorial · Reviewed November 16, 2026 · Educational information only — not tax, legal or investment advice.